Tummy Treasure real family, real food. all the time.
Budget-Friendly Ideas

Homemade Buttery Spread

By Erika
245,786 Comments 3 Min Read

I’m not sure what to call this stuff.  My post the other day about eating real food caused me to reflect on what we spread on bread.   Traditionally, we don’t use butter in my house.  I don’t buy margarine either, but I do buy butter spreads- our favorite being Brummel & Brown.  So we use this spreadable stuff on bread, pancakes, waffles, toast, and things of that nature.  The appeal of the spreads is that they are spreadable right out of the fridge- cold butter is not.  But have you ever read the label of a butter spread?  Yeah… more of those chemicals and stabilizers and things we cannot pronounce and wonder if we should be eating.

So last summer, while at my aunt and uncle’s house celebrating Independence Day, I learned very easily how to make my own spread, but then completely forgot about it until the other day.  Then, of course, that led to me asking Andy if he remembered the proportions, and a message had to be sent to find that all out.

Easy as pie.  You only need two ingredients.  A stick of real butter and 3 fluid ounces of the oil of your choice.  Choose a heart healthy oil, such as canola, olive, peanut, sunflower or safflower oil.  Personally, I prefer a neutral tasting oil as well- canola and peanut work well there.  Olive oil is good, but a nicely flavored olive oil just doesn’t taste as well to me spread on toast and sprinkled with cinnamon sugar.  But use olive oil if you prefer.  I’m using peanut today.

Let the butter soften to room temperature.  Once it’s very soft, put it in a mixing bowl along with the oil.  Use a whisk or a hand mixer to blend the two together.  Your mixture will look like unset pudding.  This is exactly the consistency you are looking for.

Then you simply pour it into a resealable container and pop it in the fridge.  The spread will set up a bit once chilled, but it’s completely spreadable cold and out of the fridge.  Perfect for using anytime a smear of butter is called for.

If you want to make it in a larger quantity, use two sticks of butter (1 cup) to 3/4 cup of oil.  And of course, you can also use this as a platform for a multitude of other uses.  Use these proportions and add garlic and herbs for an instant spread for garlic bread.  Really, creatively speaking, you could probably mix in just about anything to customize your own delicious spreads straight out of the fridge.  Just keep in mind that fresh foods, like fruit bits, fresh garlic and herbs will shorten the shelf life to about a week.  But I imagine they could be frozen for long term storage.

Homemade spreadable butter.  It’s an excellent thing and a great budget stretcher.

Filed In Budget-Friendly Ideas

About the author

Erika

245,786 Responses

  1. Belle Colon

    Valuable information! Find more at water heater repair .

  2. Cordelia Carlson

    Home cleansing isn’t my beloved chore, so I’m definitely considering employing a house cleaning in Idaho Falls .

  3. Danny Rogers

    Your tips on choosing the right HVAC contractor were very helpful! It can be overwhelming trying to find someone trustworthy. ac repair

  4. Brandon Walker

    This was quite helpful. For more, visit auto repair 27701 .

  5. Belle Moore

    I’m amazed by how effective CoolSculpting is! More info at american laser med spa coolsculpting appointments el paso .

  6. Elnora Hoffman

    Thanks for the comprehensive read. Find more at Local Medicare Agents .

  7. Robert Lloyd

    I love when cities invest in restoring older playgrounds instead of building new ones from scratch! Let’s talk about sustainability at playground line marking .

  8. Bess Goodman

    This was quite informative. More at https://maps.app.goo.gl/dgt3RZMe97oxStTb6 .

  9. Jane Black

    Thanks for the insightful write-up. More like this at Local pet dental .

  10. Brian Owens

    ???????????, ??? ???? ??????? ??????? ????? ???????? ?????????? ???? ????????! https://edgarmqpz.bloggersdelight.dk/2025/04/30/brending-i-marketing-chto-nuzhno-znat-tashkentskim-predprinimatelyam/

  11. Ollie Hill

    “Is there anything specific I should look out for during my initial consultation with Americans Medical Spas –Midland?” american laser body contouring

  12. Juan Ortiz

    This was a wonderful guide. Check out foothills paving and maintenance for more.

  13. Jorge Washington

    Anyone know of good ##gas engineers near me##? I need help with my heating system. Boiler repair | Prema Plumbing Putney

  14. Georgia Washington

    OMG OneMoreGlass ????????????????????????????????????????????1 ???????????????????! ???????????????? ???1

  15. Katharine Lamb

    Thanks for the useful post. More like this at https://maps.app.goo.gl/LeVvzHhy8BfX7vWB9 .

  16. Roxie Pierce

    This was very enlightening. For more, visit trusted MMD licensed physicians .

  17. Travis Gilbert

    Appreciate the thorough insights. For more, visit Click here! .

  18. Gerald Schmidt

    Thanks for the thorough analysis. More info at https://maps.app.goo.gl/ddbtHVgZmySgYMAs7 .

  19. Frances Patrick

    This was quite enlightening. Check out Summers Plumbing Heating & Cooling for more.

  20. Daniel Hampton

    “I’m eager to learn more about lighting techniques mentioned in this post.” video recording studio

  21. Hettie Baldwin

    Wonderful tips! Find more at https://maps.app.goo.gl/jsc9JRFLYgwivrRHA .

  22. Jeffrey Thomas

    The support from my Anchorage car accident lawyer was incredible during such a stressful time! For more information, visit https://jsbin.com/geliruzehe today!

  23. Jackson Mullins

    This was very enlightening. For more, visit best Medicare agents near me .

  24. Angel Christensen

    I appreciated this article. For more, visit roof repair .

  25. Lloyd Porter

    I found this very helpful. For additional info, visit pet chiropractor nearby .

  26. Olive Oliver

    septic companies Mooresville

  27. Helen Allison

    I enjoyed this post. For additional info, visit water damage restoration companies .

  28. Brett Garrett

    Kudos to all those who support nearby ### Idaho Falls house cleaners

  29. Mattie Arnold

    Thanks for the thorough article. Find more at affordable asphalt maintenance Foothills .

  30. Lillie Pope

    ?????????? ????????? – ??? ?????????? ???????, ??????? ??????? ??????? ? ??????! https://www.cheaperseeker.com/u/percanxqmq

  31. Lillie Pope

    ?????????? ????????? – ??? ?????????? ???????, ??????? ??????? ??????? ? ??????! https://www.cheaperseeker.com/u/percanxqmq

  32. Mittie Bell

    This was very beneficial. For more, visit MMD Family Doctors .

  33. Ralph Barker

    Great job! Discover more at Montgomery Roofing – Lorena Roofers .

  34. Troy Kelly

    Love the friendly tone of this blog post—it makes understanding technical details so much easier; can’t wait to check out similar topics over at hvac installation #!

  35. Alta Harrington

    Thanks for the useful post. More like this at https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Summers+Plumbing+Heating+%26+Cooling,+1609+Rank+Pkwy+Ct,+Kokomo,+IN+46901,+United+States/Meijer,+East+Markland+Avenue,+Kokomo,+IN,+USA/@40.4861275,-86.1117086,14.5z/data=!4m13!4m12!1m5!1m1!1s0x8814860dc2579fdd:0x326850a41a3156c8!2m2!1d-86.1099812!2d40.4965429!1m5!1m1!1s0x881485f08d019811:0xe1eef4fd016d7fbf!2m2!1d-86.1008468!2d40.4745122?entry=ttu&g_ep=EgoyMDI1MDQzMC4xIKXMDSoASAFQAw%3D%3D .

  36. Adelaide Reyes

    Thanks for the informative post. More at local Medicare agents near me .

  37. Richard Santos

    ?????????? ? ??????????? ????? ?????? ??????????; ??????, ??? ????? ???????? ?????? ????????????????! https://www.mediafire.com/file/5ynfa3lyeuvgwhp/pdf-50942-79130.pdf/file

  38. Richard Santos

    ?????????? ? ??????????? ????? ?????? ??????????; ??????, ??? ????? ???????? ?????? ????????????????! https://www.mediafire.com/file/5ynfa3lyeuvgwhp/pdf-50942-79130.pdf/file

  39. Lillian Lamb

    Just wondering how soon after booking should clients expect updates related progress being made towards final destinations?! **## any Keyword** Long distance movers Ochopee

  40. Erik Wheeler

    Nicely detailed. Discover more at https://maps.app.goo.gl/gzyJ3aFdaK1vJBHFA .

  41. Charlotte Jennings

    I enjoyed this read. For more, visit roofing services .

  42. Connor Rose

    The electricity of social media in gaining knowledge of exquisite new salons is simple; I’ve came across some factual gemstones currently!!! Let’s rejoice social media’s influence at the same time the following: # # anyKeyWord ## hair salon west vancouver Wish Dry Bar – Hair Salon

  43. Rosetta Porter

    Appreciate the comprehensive insights. For more, visit https://maps.app.goo.gl/jqk2f4rMVkXTdc74A .

  44. Devin Vargas

    Wow—the expertise shown by ### ankeyword ### made this transition enjoyable rather than overwhelming! Office moving companies Bradenton

  45. Jean Powers

    What’s the most challenging part of running a successful video recording studio? video recording studio

  46. Roxie Watson

    Appreciate the thorough write-up. Find more at foothills paving and maintenance .

  47. Marie Christensen

    Kerner Law Group, P.C. is my top recommendation for anyone needing a Bronx car accident attorney! Their dedication is unmatched.
    I had a fantastic experience with Kerner Law Group, P.C. Their team includes the best Bronx car accident lawyer I’ve ever met No-fault car accident attorney Bronx

  48. Owen Hayes

    In case anyone needs motivation today: think of outcomes achieved after collaborating closely alongside experts! West Palm Beach moving company

  49. Victor Myers

    Daniella Levi & Associates, P.C. gave me peace of mind with their exceptional Brooklyn car accident attorney services!
    I couldn’t be happier with the support from Daniella Levi & Associates, P.C Pedestrian accident lawyer Brooklyn

  50. Bettie Holloway

    This was quite helpful. For more, visit https://maps.app.goo.gl/iToVt7TCryVMwHSr9 .

Comments are closed.