Tummy Treasure real family, real food. all the time.
Budget-Friendly Ideas

Homemade Buttery Spread

By Erika
245,786 Comments 3 Min Read

I’m not sure what to call this stuff.  My post the other day about eating real food caused me to reflect on what we spread on bread.   Traditionally, we don’t use butter in my house.  I don’t buy margarine either, but I do buy butter spreads- our favorite being Brummel & Brown.  So we use this spreadable stuff on bread, pancakes, waffles, toast, and things of that nature.  The appeal of the spreads is that they are spreadable right out of the fridge- cold butter is not.  But have you ever read the label of a butter spread?  Yeah… more of those chemicals and stabilizers and things we cannot pronounce and wonder if we should be eating.

So last summer, while at my aunt and uncle’s house celebrating Independence Day, I learned very easily how to make my own spread, but then completely forgot about it until the other day.  Then, of course, that led to me asking Andy if he remembered the proportions, and a message had to be sent to find that all out.

Easy as pie.  You only need two ingredients.  A stick of real butter and 3 fluid ounces of the oil of your choice.  Choose a heart healthy oil, such as canola, olive, peanut, sunflower or safflower oil.  Personally, I prefer a neutral tasting oil as well- canola and peanut work well there.  Olive oil is good, but a nicely flavored olive oil just doesn’t taste as well to me spread on toast and sprinkled with cinnamon sugar.  But use olive oil if you prefer.  I’m using peanut today.

Let the butter soften to room temperature.  Once it’s very soft, put it in a mixing bowl along with the oil.  Use a whisk or a hand mixer to blend the two together.  Your mixture will look like unset pudding.  This is exactly the consistency you are looking for.

Then you simply pour it into a resealable container and pop it in the fridge.  The spread will set up a bit once chilled, but it’s completely spreadable cold and out of the fridge.  Perfect for using anytime a smear of butter is called for.

If you want to make it in a larger quantity, use two sticks of butter (1 cup) to 3/4 cup of oil.  And of course, you can also use this as a platform for a multitude of other uses.  Use these proportions and add garlic and herbs for an instant spread for garlic bread.  Really, creatively speaking, you could probably mix in just about anything to customize your own delicious spreads straight out of the fridge.  Just keep in mind that fresh foods, like fruit bits, fresh garlic and herbs will shorten the shelf life to about a week.  But I imagine they could be frozen for long term storage.

Homemade spreadable butter.  It’s an excellent thing and a great budget stretcher.

Filed In Budget-Friendly Ideas

About the author

Erika

245,786 Responses

  1. Mario Bush

    This was very enlightening. More at Airdrie eye doctor

  2. Lucile Singleton

    This article really opened my eyes to the nutritional value of feeder quail affordable frozen quail

  3. Lena McGuire

    Painting can be daunting, but finding the right residential painter in Leander, TX made all the difference painting company

  4. Emily Kelley

    Thanks for sharing these insights! I’ve learned that investing in HVAC repair saves money in the long run HVAC repair

  5. Hettie Cox

    Great job! Discover more at http://devinipkc484.cavandoragh.org/why-choosing-dumpster-delivered-for-your-dumpster-rental-in-hobe-sound-fl-is-a-smart-move

  6. Teresa Bass

    Clearly presented. Discover more at http://felixkzbm180.lucialpiazzale.com/from-repairs-to-replacements-comprehensive-roofing-services-offered-by-ready-roof-inc-1

  7. Mittie Washington

    I found this very interesting. For more, visit Roofing Company San Antonio

  8. Floyd Mendez

    Navigating Medicare can be daunting Health Insurance Cape Coral

  9. Gabriel Bowers

    Appreciate the insightful article. Find more at ac repair

  10. Alvin Lowe

    The thrill of hitting a jackpot is unmatched! I had that experience on arena plus recently

  11. Eula Hernandez

    Thanks for the insightful write-up. More like this at http://kameronrryd467.lowescouponn.com/revitalize-your-outdoor-space-expert-tips-for-fence-cleaning-from-your-quality-pressure-washing

  12. Adam Stone

    This is very insightful. Check out Restoration services for more

  13. Pauline Christensen

    Skup nieruchomo?ci to idealna opcja dla tych, którzy potrzebuj? natychmiastowej gotówki za swoj? nieruchomo??. Dzi?ki temu procesowi mo?na zaoszcz?dzi? czas na poszukiwanie kupca i negocjacje cenowe skup nieruchomo?ci

  14. Patrick Medina

    Thanks for the great content. More at https://maps.app.goo.gl/1coC3o58AhXk34kPA

  15. Thomas Cole

    Proud knowing organizations exist promoting safety awareness delivering educational resources prevent future harm whilst simultaneously advocating justice where warranted accordingly!!!  ##anything# car accident lawyer

  16. Virginia Torres

    Just checked out the reviews for best AC repair in my area —seems like a solid choice for repairs

  17. Verna Reyes

    Such a thought-provoking piece! For additional thoughts, check out car accident injury lawyer

  18. Barry Cross

    Appreciate the detailed information. For more, visit https://geospasia.com/2020/04/30/zoompalitan-dan-zoombastis-2/#comment-81607

  19. Grace Carter

    I had no idea that chiropractors specialized in car accident injuries Chiropractic services for auto accidents

  20. Tillie Fuller

    Love seeing detailed guidance showcased around what makes each choice unique depending upon geographical considerations/ climate factors influencing effectiveness/results achieved overall too ! Interested individuals could benefit from touching base with Roofing contractor

  21. Jim Terry

    This is very insightful. Check out http://andersonbbho784.almoheet-travel.com/transform-your-backyard-expert-pool-installation-services-in-paterson-nj for more

  22. Julia Arnold

    This blog does an excellent job explaining why regular check-ups are necessary with our # anyKeyWord# affordable cosmetic dentist

  23. Warren Stephens

    Say goodbye to costly weight loss plans and hello to affordable CoolSculpting treatments at coolsculpting prices near me

  24. Cynthia Hart

    I highly recommend checking out coolsculpting el paso for the best Coolsculpting results out there

  25. Lura Henderson

    Really appreciate this detailed overview; it’s helped me consider contacting Avalon Roofing Services for my needs! roof repair

  26. Edna Leonard

    Tr?i nghi?m d?ch v? ch?m sóc khách hàng chu ?áo khi?n tôi thêm ph?n yên tâm khi ??t ni?m tin vào h? th?ng c?a h?!!### https://daltonfzmi.bloggersdelight.dk/2025/02/25/dang-ky-e2bet-va-kham-pha-dich-vu-ho-tro-247-tu-nha-cai-uy-tin/

  27. Edna Leonard

    Tr?i nghi?m d?ch v? ch?m sóc khách hàng chu ?áo khi?n tôi thêm ph?n yên tâm khi ??t ni?m tin vào h? th?ng c?a h?!!### https://daltonfzmi.bloggersdelight.dk/2025/02/25/dang-ky-e2bet-va-kham-pha-dich-vu-ho-tro-247-tu-nha-cai-uy-tin/

  28. Marvin Cox

    I’m looking to start a bulk buying group for canned goods in my community—this is great motivation! wholesale confectionery

  29. Vera Wright

    Appreciate the great suggestions. For more, visit mold remediation services nearby

  30. Gertrude Daniel

    I’m always amazed by the creativity of campaigns coming from Silicon Valley businesses—get inspired at marketing agency near me

  31. Jay Walsh

    ”Let us continue championing voices unheard amplifying messages resonating deeply throughout various neighborhoods united under shared mission promoting awareness necessary today now more than ever before!” truck accident lawyer

  32. Francisco Myers

    The connection between customer reviews and search rankings can’t be underestimated—great point made here! Learn more at Best Local SEO Agency

  33. Evelyn Vaughn

    Appreciate the detailed insights. For more, visit discover free online

  34. Mark Thompson

    Appreciate detailed comparisons between traditional versus cutting-edge technologies discussed across different sections throughout site content!!!!!!   HVAC repair

  35. Lillian Dunn

    I love exploring different themes in slot games arena plus

  36. Wesley Lane

    Helpful suggestions! For more, visit vision of the ISOS organization

  37. Floyd Craig

    This was quite useful. For more, visit Roofing company nearby

  38. Hettie Hernandez

    If you’ve been injured due to someone else’s recklessness accident lawyer

  39. Clara Burton

    I found this very interesting. For more, visit Bird Dog Trainer Tucson

  40. Connor Barton

    So many excellent points made throughout this Orlando Waste Management

  41. Virgie Sullivan

    Appreciate the insightful article. Find more at furnace repair

  42. Floyd Davis

    Very useful post. For similar content, visit Sewer line repair near me

  43. Hannah Garrett

    I’m excited about my upcoming move top rated moving company Vero Beach

  44. Nettie McKenzie

    I enjoyed this article. Check out roof repair houston for more

  45. Roger Adkins

    Appreciate the detailed insights. For more, visit payday loans no credit check

  46. Anne Vega

    Thanks for the informative content. More at Oro Valley Realtor

  47. Thomas James

    If you’re intending a winter season occasion, take into consideration the advantages of portable heater rental. It can actually keep your guests comfy! Have a look at portable heater rental for fantastic options

  48. Francis Fox

    Thanks for the useful post. More like this at https://maps.app.goo.gl/NStZMByZdUMCZNj89

  49. Leroy Schultz

    Thanks for the great information. More at cheap car hire

  50. Mollie Barnes

    I enjoyed this read. For more, visit abogados santiago de compostela

Comments are closed.